Well, there was an abundance of texts and incidents to show the sin of lying, and the evil consequences which must follow it. And nobody, either then or now, needed any particular instruction about the sin of the old prophet. But the world needed a lesson on the subject of believing a lie; so the young prophet was slain to teach this lesson, while the old man was left to God’s ordinary method of dealing with liars. No doubt he got his deserts sooner or later. Friends, this very singular piece of inspired history confirms most strikingly, and illustrates most aptly the teaching of Paul and of Jesus on the subject of believing a lie ‑ of being guided by blind guides.
Shall we think, then, that every man who believes a lie in regard to God’s will shall perish? We think not. If a blind man is guided by another blind man along a smooth road, where there is no ditch, neither of them will fall into a ditch. It is only when there is a ditch in the way that they will fall into it. So, if this young prophet had been told to do almost anything else than what he was told to do, we have no reason to think it would have been fatal. If, for example, the old prophet had said, An angel sent me to tell you to get from under this tree and run for your life, and not to stop until you get home, the young man would have been scared, and would have run himself out of breath; but the lion would not have killed him.
In like manner, we can imagine a man believing some lies in religion, which, though they may injure him some (and there are very few that would not), might yet fall far short of proving fatal to him. We think that the doctrine of election as taught in the old creeds is false in the extreme; but many a man has believed it all his life, and then possibly gone on to be with God when he died. What, then, is the distinction? It is to be traced out by remembering that there is only one thing that can keep men out of heaven, or keep them estranged from God in this life. That one thing is sin (cf. Isa. 59:1-2). Nothing else does or can stand between God and any man. If the belief of a lie, then, leads a man to commit sin, it will prove fatal unless that sin shall be forgiven. It was thus with the young prophet. The lie that he believed led him to disobey God. His disobedience was the immediate cause, while the belief of a lie was only the remote cause of his death.
How Can We Determine Truth? Sometimes lies have the same effect as truth. If one hears the truth and obeys it, he then feels secure and safe. However, some have heard a lie, believed the lie, obeyed the lie, and felt safe and secure. In view of the solemn lesson now before us, taught both in the Old Testament and in the New, it becomes a question of transcendent importance: How shall we be sure that we are NOT believing lies; that we are not being led by blind guides? How are we going to determine truth from a lie concerning our soul’s salvation? If I am a blind man myself, I should have more sense than to let another blind man guide me. He may guide me a little way and not lead me into a ditch; but when I start to follow his guidance, I cannot know but that the second step I take will be a sudden plunge into a ditch from which I cannot get out. I must, then, take pains to let no one guide me but those who can see.
View on YouTube